We Hold 1 of 3 Governing Beliefs: We are Better, Less or Equal
Mary McInnis
Posted on December 5, 2017
As human beings, you and I have exactly three choices for what we believe about ourselves and others:
1) I am better than others
2) I am less than others
3) I am equal to others.
I’m calling these the Three Self Belief States.
And what we believe about ourselves is also what we believe about the groups we identify with. Our group is better (the “haves”), less (the “have nots”), or equal (wait, what?).
Fact: being identified with our groups (religious, cultural, racial, socio-economic, vocational, avocational) causes self belief to become elevated for some and eroded for others. The consequences of this are very apparent today. The division between the elevated and the eroded is a self-fulfilling (ironic, I know) process with an outcome of more division, more polarized self beliefs (one way better, the other way less), and a loss of ability to sense our shared humanity.
Disclaimer: This won’t be easy to read. Read it anyway. It’s not that long – and therefore it is blunt. It is meant to shake you up, no matter the group you identify with. And maybe, shake you loose of some things that can stand to go.
I am going to start with the Self Belief State of being LESS. Trust me on this.
Self Belief State: LESS
In this belief state, I believe my group and I are less than others, don’t deserve what others have.
(This is what life is like for many who are in a marginalized group. And in our country now, more and more are being marginalized.)
With this belief I will either feel (a) eroded, (b) betrayed, or (c) awakening.
Eroded
I see all of society’s proof that I am undeserving and I believe it. I have witnessed the “truth” of my situation from the eyes of the “haves,” those in power. My self belief is eroded. Hope is not on my radar.
I am eroded.
Betrayed
I see hope – but only through conformity, adopting the norms of the “haves” even when it goes against things that really matter to me. It requires me to betray myself. It is not true hope, but it is all I have.
I am betrayed.
Awakening
I am not undeserving. I question the “truths” I had accepted. And hope starts to become true, belief in self starts to become true, and deservingness starts to become true.
I am on my way.
Where? To Self Belief State: EQUAL.*
(*Note that oppression can cause someone to flip to Self Belief State: BETTER as a temporary measure to overcome debilitating self beliefs. More on that in Self Belief State: Equal)
Self Belief State: BETTER
In this belief state, I believe my group and I are better than others, more deserving.
(We can see this clearly in many groups in our country now. Supremacism, nationalism, isolationism are happening.)
With this belief I will either feel (a) rightful, (b) conditionally caring, or (c) awakening.
Rightful
I will rightfully base my decisions in the interests of me and mine, upholding us as the deserving ones. If my decisions hurt those not in the deserving group, so be it.
I am rightful.**
(**I originally had “self-righteous” here. Yeah. That’s a trigger. And it’s also a word, with a definition, that has an application, and this is that application. But I cut it. Oh, and I told you about it so I kinda didn’t.)
Conditionally Caring
I will “help” others to become more deserving – coerce them to comply with my group’s norms, what my group professes as true, and abandon their own truths (i.e. “mission work”). I will care about others only if they elevate my truths above theirs.
I am conditionally caring.
Awakening
I begin to realize my group’s deservingness is based in a paradigm that I have either been born into, or have had the privilege to be able to choose. I begin to consider other measures of deservingness on my way to doing away with the concept that some are more deserving than others altogether.
I am on my way.
Self Belief State: EQUAL is in sight.
Self Belief State: EQUAL
This one is the hardest. We have to fight to establish ourselves here, because ingrained biases and daily societal treatment tell us the opposite. At any given time we may feel better than or less than another. And we have to intervene when we do, look at what’s at work, why we feel what we do, and correct ourselves.
Yes. We must repeatedly correct ourselves – bring ourselves back to a place where we recognize the bias at play and see it for what it is: a lie. Bring ourselves back to a place of truth. A place where I am deserving, you are deserving – and the very concept of “deserving” can be eliminated.
The Self Belief States of Better and Less were never meant to be permanent human experiences. The irony is that people get stuck in them so deeply that even the idea of a state where there are no “haves” or “have nots” is inconceivable. We choose to live permanently in states that are meant to be temporary – states we should only have to be in long enough to get woke enough to move out of them. And while we stay in these states, we are choosing to uphold biases, untruths.
Getting out of the Self Belief States of Better and Less requires taking hard steps to move into the only truly sustainable, truly permanent, state of truth: unity. All who are in this are equal. All are one. We are the same.
The only true, enduring belief about yourself, then, is that you are equal.
So I fooled you. There is really only one Self Belief State. And it includes every single self on the planet. Can you establish yourself there? It is where you belong, it is where I belong, and it is the only place where everyone belongs.
Tagged: Beliefs, deserving, group norms, In Group, isolationism, nationalism, Out Group, superiority, supremacy
Love… <3
Cool! FYI, it’s revised for better delivery… and reception. 😛
Great food for thought that I’ll be processing over and over again. Thank you!
Well, Melanie, I revised this blog just now, because I felt the topic needed to be addressed in a way that lets more people in the door to see what’s shown inside. And I developed what’s shown a bit more. And now I am in a gooder-feel place about it. So your processing? It may get easier!
Thanks for sharing Mary.
Thanks, Tim. This piece was gnawing at me today so I revised it, FYI. It’s a little more… accessible now.
Definitely worth the wait. I love how you lay it out like a proof and then BAM!
Thank you! And so I got up today and did one FINAL brush-up on the piece. I think some of the words I used implied things I didn’t want implied. So it was all ideal-word-choice-mode here this morning and I think I GOT IT.
Fun fact – this is the first blog I wrote that I didn’t sleep on. Yeah, prior to this every blog I wrote had content that I had gotten to the point of saying “yes I absolutely stand by this” before publishing. This one, though, I tried something new. And found out the editing is gonna happen anyway, until I can absolutely stand by it. And I think I’m there now?
Colonel Cathcart from Catch 22 is constantly comparing himself to others. He is proud of the fact that at only the age of 36 he has already achieved the rank of Colonel whereas many men his own age and older have not achieved nearly as much. BETTER. On the other hand he is ashamed, he is disappointed in himself, that at the age of 36 he is only a Colonel, and many men his own age and younger have achieved higher rank. LESS. There is a book read in Social Stratification sociology class in the late 70s entitled the Hidden Injuries of Class. The damage that status, prestige, power do to people’s souls. So extreme inequality is not just that of wealth and income.
Agreed, Mark, thank you for this. Inequality goes on at a depth of the heart, the soul, and that’s why it’s so critical we see its damage. I believe the most important deservingness measure – the one that is able to do the most damage or conversely the most healing – is this: do I deserve to be heard? Indeed, it is not just about society’s material “riches” and who is deserving of them, but the riches of the — heart? Soul? When deservingness of this kind is something we believe we all possess, when it is an equal right, everyone is allowed the full access to their voice, and that voice is heard no matter the speaker or the recipient. That person is validated. That person believes in their own inherent value.
Also, I would like to point out that the Colonel is moving between temporary belief states while his perception of his deservingness is not equal. Being able to move out of either of these states is huge, and gets people moving toward equality.
“Colonel Cathcart was impervious to absolutes. He could measure his own progress only in relationship to others, and his idea of excellence was to do something at least as well as all the men his own age who were doing the same thing even better.”
― Joseph Heller, Catch-22
Colonel Cathcart from Catch 22 is constantly comparing himself to others. Am I less than? Am I more than, better than? The politics of demonizing your political opponent indulges the better than. It comes from an insecurity about being less than, not as much as and is such a relief from than by projecting that attitude out toward others. Our culture of status and prestige and patriarchy and racism and power is traumatizing.
Thank You for this Mary! 💜
“Colonel Cathcart was impervious to absolutes. He could measure his own progress only in relationship to others, and his idea of excellence was to do something at least as well as all the men his own age who were doing the same thing even better.”
― Joseph Heller, Catch-22